Monday, December 3, 2012

Coaching and Race - Wes Gates

I decided to write this post about a recent topic that has hit the news in which Colorado football coach Jon Embree was claimed to be fired due to race.  Embree was recently fired after only his second year coaching Colorado.  Ironically, these claims were not made by him but rather a former coach that is white.  Bill McCartney, the former coach, says that Embree was not given the same opportunity to build up the football program that a white coach would be given.  He did not inherit very much talent and the Colorado football program has struggled mightily over the last decade.  McCartney even went on to state he received more than two years for a similar situation and claimed it was in large part due to being Caucasian.

This got me thinking about how this situation was handled and if it was right or wrong.  Colorado did have a winless season and in a conference like the Pac-12, this is unacceptable.  College revenue sports are a business and I firmly believe there is a "win now" attitude by big time institutions.  From this standpoint, I can justify the firing of Embree.  On the other side, two years isn't a long time to attempt to turn around a struggling football program.  What I find alarming is that a former white coach came public with these remarks about race being a big issue.  The following ESPN article contains a very good video article explaining what happened and possible rationale for the firing:

http://espn.go.com/college-football/story/_/id/8685399/former-colorado-buffaloes-coach-blames-racism-jon-embree-firing

In my opinion, it is more difficult for a Non-Caucasian to get a head coaching job in the NCAA.  Looking around college sports there aren't too many that come to mind and when they get hired, it is made a big deal revolving around race.  Does anyone else feel this way or have a different thought?

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

WNBA Comparison- Gene Csakany



To start, I was on a plane last Tuesday, heading back home to New Jersey.  Instead of just looking at the slides to see what we discussed and having an opinion about it, when I was not there seemed kind of foolish, so instead I would like to talk about the final presentation.  My group had a very interesting theme that we followed and that was the WNBA vs. NBA.  We compared basically everything there is to compare with the two leagues.  The differences among them are far from comprehendible.  There simply is not one statistical figure that is anywhere near each other in regards to the two league, yet many people think it is unfair that the WNBA is not televised or earning more money.  The games were found to be less exciting in our research, the salaries were know where near  each other, and the attendance was so far off as well.  When looking specifically at the salaries, most would say that it is typical women make less than men for doing the same thing, but that is not the case here.  Although both basketball, the WNBA and NBA are two completely different professional leagues and the game is played in two totally different ways.  Also the WNBA has such a significantly lower net worth that some NBA teams could nearly buy out the entire WNBA league.  It is expected that when attendance is so low, players should be paid less.  When attendance averages more than double in the NBA, why wouldn’t those players get paid more?  Granted some of their pay is outrageous to the common person like you or I, but plain and simple the sports are way too different in nearly every aspect to be compared fairly.

Monday, November 26, 2012

The End of Gary Bettman


This blog has nothing to do with transgender athletes or any gender issue at all.  This blog is about the ongoing lockout that the National Hockey League is going through, and what has been a way to common occurrence under the commissioner Gary Bettman.  Bettman has overseen three lockouts now since he took over as commissioner in 1993 after he left the NBA; as he served under David Stern, who is a questionable commissioner himself.  Bettman has supposedly taken the NHL to new heights in regards to revenue, but that is a bunch of crap.  He has single handedly saturated the league with unnecessary expansion teams, not to mention the labor disputes that he has helped use to bully small market teams time and time again.  He has put NHL teams in markets like Columbus, Nashville, Carolina, Florida (Miami and Tampa), Phoenix, and created a team based off of a Disney movie (the Mighty Ducks) who have no place to succeed financially.  Bettman has put teams in cities such as these to create a fallback during labor disputes to pad his pockets because the owners of these teams cannot oppose what the majority of owners say because their teams have very little pull due to being small players in a large financial game.  Phoenix is owned by the NHL and cannot draw fans to their games even though they are somewhat successful; a team does not belong in the southwestern portion of America; let alone the Grand Canyon.  Put that team in Canada Bettman; where it belongs.  Fire Bettman, and this is the end of my rant.

Go Rangers! And lets play some hockey.

Derek Zyski

Kye Allums


In class last week we talked about transgender athletes and among them mentioned was Kye Allums. He is a transgendered male who currently plays on George Washington University woman’s basketball team. Allums is considered a transgendered male because he has female parts but feels as if he should have been born male with male parts. He is 21 years old and he is totally public about his sexuality. He is dedicated to winning and helping out the team win as much as possible. In his pursuit of this he hopes to inspire other transgendered people to come out and not be afraid to be who they really are. Kye feels like a man does, both emotionally and mentally. He is attracted to other females, which for most teams that might cause some tension but since the other players have been playing with her since the beginning they are alright with it. His plan once his eligibility at GW is up is to have testosterone treatments and surgery to have male parts. Allums original plan was to open up after the eligibility was up but due to remarks from others that were calling him “her” and a “girl” was too much for Kye to take anymore. He felt like he was living a lie so he had to come clean and tell everyone how he really felt. Since coming out his coach has embraced him and treated him no different than he did before.

The question of conflict here is whether or not he should be allowed to play on the woman’s team if he is a male? If he was born a male then there would be no question on if he could play on the woman’s team, it would obviously be no. Let’s say there was a male, born with male parts, but was transgendered female so he felt like he should be a female. Would he be allowed to play on a woman’s team or should he have to play on the men’s team? What are your thoughts? Should Kye Allums be playing on the woman’s basketball team?
 
 
BY: RJ Hefflinger

Richard Raskind to Renee Richards

In Tuesday's class we talked about transsexuality in sports. The main athlete we discussed was Renee Richards, formerly known as Richard Raskind. Richards was an optometrist who also became very active in Women's tennis after her sex reassignment surgery. There was controversy over whether or not Richards should be allowed to compete against other women, as she was genetically born a male. Even though Richards was born a male, after the surgery, she was physically a female, having gone through all the surgical procedures and even undergoing hormonal therapy. The question, Should she have been allowed to play in Women's Tennis was brought up in class. I think that she should be allowed. She underwent the hard process of becoming a female and she was physically female. Many critics believed having previous been a male gave her a strength advantage, as her muscle build was primarily male. I think what made the difference was the hormone treatment. Richards even stated that she had experienced a loss of strength from her hormone treatment in her defense. I believe that the authorities made the right decision in allowing her to play. She was a physically a woman and this was the body she was comfortable in. Granted, there might have been a slight advantage strength wise, but I do not think this should have prevented her from being able to play in the women's league.
In class we also watched a Youtube clip of Renee being interviewed by ESPN right before the airing of her 30 for 30 television special. In the interview she stated how she loved tennis, but it is not what she wanted to be remembered for. She did so many other things in her life successfully like optometry and golf that almost no one bothered to pay attention to. She also talked about how she wishes she hadn't even entered the tennis world, as the scrutiny and fight to play were not worth it to her. I feel bad that this is how Renee looks back on her tennis career. She was a good tennis player, but some people just could not get passed the fact that she was transsexual. Renee put up a good fight for herself, and she was successful. Her case went all the way to the Supreme Court, where they ruled her biologically a female, allowing her to play in the women's league. It is just sad that Renee Richards has this outlook on her career, and that not many people know the extent of her abilities past tennis since this got the most publicity.

Jennifer Zoellick

Monday, November 19, 2012

Homosexual Support/Religious Scrutiny

Over the course of this class, we have been talking about very controversial things. Topics such as homosexuality, race, and etc. are conversations that have been very popular recently, but something that has not been touched is religion. Revealing your religion in sports is almost as dangerous as revealing your sexuality. Once you reveal your religion you are placed under constant scrutiny from the media, and immediately held to a higher standard.

Let's take a look at my favorite professional athlete, Tim Tebow. Tim has been very strong in his faith throughout his career, and also has been very vocal about it as well. Because of this he not only has been scrutinized he also has been forced to live his life under a microscope. This is not only unfair, but it also shows how pathetic our society is today. We talk about supporting gay rights and other very controversial issues like this in society, but when something like this happens it is frowned upon. It is not only sad, but it is almost pathetic! Our media keeps discussing issues such as we need someone to come out in athletics that is gay to give younger generations someone to look up to. Well in my opinion, this is a backwards situation. Tim Tebow is a man that I would be proud to have my kids look up to and lives his life in a way that each of us should respect. I don't understand how he gets torn apart in the media and is the but of almost every joke because he is a strong religious leader, and people who live their life in "sin" are being supported to come out. I just wanted to show what a backwards society we live in, and point out a controversial issue that has been brushed under the rug so many times in todays society.


Supported Vs. Scrutiny

                 

Fear of the Gay Athlete- Gene Csakany



During most of last week we spoke about gay athletes, more specifically, gay professional athletes, or lack thereof.  This is even more evident in male sports, and that’s what’s most interesting because in female athletics today, it is not that big of a deal if a female comes out, but if a male comes out, all hell breaks loose.  This is mostly because of the degree of masculinity associated with male sports.  People want to be referred to as a, “beast”, “animal” or “warrior”, but no male in sports wants to be affiliated with the negative connotation associated with being gay.  Being gay in sports has been associated basically with a disease.  As terrible as that sounds, it is one hundred percent true, especially in the locker room setting.  All men who have been involved with athletics knows what is said and talked about in the male locker room, and to throw someone who is gay into that situation just would not work out.  This is why many athletes that are gay, come out after their playing careers.  They will be isolated to themselves, or quarantined as if gay was truly a disease.  Many popular athletes have said that they do not think it would be a big deal and they would not treat them differently if they came out.  That is what you are “suppose” to say, not many people really know exactly what they would do because it honestly has not happen, and if it has it has been covered up very well.  It goes to show that while race and gender in sports may be breaching the gap between being separated or causing a problem; but being gay still has not been understood and accepted in athletics, more specifically male athletics.