Monday, November 12, 2012

Maintaining Feminity For Female Athletes -Gene Csakany



I thought our discussions in last Tuesday and Thursday’s classes were very interesting.  We briefly started to talk about hockey and the “Lebron James” of the NHL, in Sidney Crosby.  We touched on the fact that like Lebron, Crosby is regarded as the best player in his sport, but many people do not like him and attach many negative characteristics with him personally as well as his playing ability.  But this still was not the most interesting part of the discussion when we talked about hockey.  The Canadian Women’s hockey team won gold at the 2010 Olympics and celebrated in a very interesting way.  They proceeded to drink beer and smoke cigars on the ice, and it was said it was a big deal only because of the fact that supposedly an underage team member was seen drinking alcohol.  That clearly was not the problem.  In our society women are basically required to maintain a certain level of femininity to be seen as a female athlete.  If the men’s team won gold and celebrated like this, it most likely would not be a big deal because men are typically stereotyped with drinking beer and smoking cigars.  Women are “suppose” to be classy and not partake in that type of celebration even though their team victory was clearly something to celebrate.  We then went into further detail on Thursday’s class and while in groups we concluded that many females feel the need to wear “skimpy” clothing in magazines or show more skin in general in order to maintain that feminine persona and not be given a negative connotation for being a female athlete.  Unless it is illegal, not many people give male athletes the same negative connotations for anything they do on or off the playing field.  Men are supposed to play sports in our society and be “manly” and tough.  But it is interesting that when women play, they have to fight obstacles of femininity just because of outsider perception.  

3 comments:

  1. Gene-
    I completely agree with what you say about there being a different standard being held towards women. Especially when you say that if the men's team cracked some beers and smoked cigars after a win on the ice, it'd be no big deal. (Personally I would turn into Stone Cold Steve Austin and being slamming beers together and chugging them if I had ever won a gold medal; and that's the bottom line, but that's a different story.) The women's team should be able to drink all the Molsons, Crown, and Labatt's they want after accomplishing something like that. Now on to Crosby; I am one of those people who think that he is a crybaby and should not be regarded as the next Gretzky. Crosby hides behind his teammates after he does something to tick off the other team, and it's just sad. He will never be the "Great One" or even "One of the Greats"

    Derek Zyski

    ReplyDelete
  2. As I said in class I believe Alexander Ovechkin is more like LeBron than is Crosby. Although I agree that Crosby is probably the better hockey player, Ovechkin can be the most dominant. With his size, athleticism and skill, Ovechkin poses this threat of single handedly taking over a game much like LeBron. Also, I don't see LeBron as the "face" of the NBA as Crosby is to the NHL. LeBron will definitely go down as one of the greatest players in NBA history, but I don't see him as the icon of the NBA.
    -Michael Discipio

    ReplyDelete
  3. I completely agree with the post that gender was the main issue involving why the Canadian Women's national team was scrutinized for their celebration.

    http://www.criminaljusticedegreesguide.com/uncategorized/9-most-frequently-broken-laws.html

    Above is a link for the nine most frequently broken laws in America. The second most frequently broken law is underage drinking, falling short only to speeding, which I'm sure everyone has done at least as some point in their lives. The point I'm trying to make is that because a girl is underage drinking on the ice really isn't an issue. I think its because the women's hockey team wasn't acting stereotypically "lady-like" with their celebration that attracted so much negative attention.

    One of the greatest things about being apart of a team is celebrating with them after a big game and you should be able to celebrate however you like, male or female.

    -Ollie Goss

    ReplyDelete